https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utilisateur:Salem_elkotamy
Key Points
- It seems likely that Salem Elkotamy, an Egyptian political dissident living in France, is the author of the statements provided, given his known critical stance against the Egyptian government and his history of using strong, provocative language.
- The statements reflect his call for civil disobedience and armed resistance against the regime, aligning with his broader advocacy for revolutionary change and support for Islamist causes, particularly in Egypt and Palestine.
- Research suggests these views are controversial, as they challenge the current Egyptian leadership and could be seen as incitement, potentially leading to legal repercussions in Egypt.
- The photo shared, likely of Elkotamy with his children, humanizes him, showing his personal life amidst his political activism, which might be an unexpected insight into his motivations.
Direct Answer
Salem Elkotamy is likely the person behind these statements, given his background as an Egyptian political dissident living in France since around 2016. He’s known for criticizing the Egyptian government, especially President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, and supporting Islamist movements like the Muslim Brotherhood. These statements, calling for civil disobedience on June 5 and threatening armed resistance, fit his pattern of advocating for revolutionary change, particularly against what he sees as a tyrannical regime. They also show his strong support for the Palestinian cause, urging action against Israel and perceived traitorous Arab leaders.
However, these views are controversial. In Egypt, where dissent is heavily suppressed with over 65,000 political prisoners reported, such calls could be seen as incitement, risking legal action. The language used, like labeling regimes as "satanic" or using offensive terms, might alienate some, even among opponents, due to its intensity. The photo you shared, possibly of Elkotamy with his children in Paris, adds a personal touch, suggesting his activism is driven by a desire for a better future for his family and nation, which might make his calls more relatable.
It’s important to note that while his blog and social media posts, like those from April 2025 calling for opening the Rafah crossing, show recent activity, the feasibility of his demands is limited by Egypt’s repressive environment and international support for the regime. His influence seems confined to exile communities, and his extreme rhetoric might not lead to practical change soon.
For more details, you can check his blog at Salem Elkotamy's Blog.
Survey Note: Comprehensive Analysis of Salem Elkotamy's Statements and Context
Introduction
Salem Elkotamy, born on March 20, 1962, in Arab El Iraq village, Qalyubia Governorate, Egypt, is a political dissident known for his blog and social media presence, where he criticizes the Egyptian government under President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi and other Arab regimes for perceived collaboration with Israel and the West. He has been living in France since approximately 2016, following the 2013 coup in Egypt, and his writings often call for resistance and revolution, particularly supporting Islamist movements like the Muslim Brotherhood. This analysis examines his recent statements, particularly his call for civil disobedience on June 5, the anniversary of the 1967 Naksa, and the implications of these views, alongside the personal photo provided, which likely humanizes his activism.
Background and Profile
Elkotamy's activism began notably with his blog posts dating back to 2008, where he criticized figures like Hosni Mubarak and later el-Sisi, using terms like "jash Sisi" (donkey Sisi) to express disdain. His move to France, possibly due to political persecution following the 2013 coup against Mohamed Morsi, aligns with reports of over 65,000 political prisoners in Egypt, as documented by [Human Rights Watch on Egypt's Crackdown]([invalid url, do not cite]). His writings, often in Arabic, are characterized by strong, sometimes inflammatory language, as seen in posts criticizing the Egyptian military's priorities and calling for resistance against what he perceives as traitorous regimes.
Recent blog posts from April 12, 2025, include discussions about his political activism, exile in France since 2005, and criticism of the Egyptian regime, sharing details of his background and opposition to various Egyptian leaders and policies. On April 11, 2025, he called for the opening of the Rafah crossing by force, using hashtags related to Gaza and the crossing, and posted a personal message wishing well for a loved one, alongside political commentary on Egyptian citizenship issues and historical grievances. He also mentioned a luxury watch by Richard Mille, though this seems unrelated to his political activities.
Analysis of the Statements
The provided statement, "I call upon every free patriot, including myself, to try on the anniversary of the Naksa, June 5, a comprehensive civil disobedience, as the last peaceful solution for change, to be a final warning to the ruling gang to voluntarily leave power," is a clear call to action. It specifies demands such as refusing to pay unjust taxes, establishing a true democracy respecting human, national, and religious dimensions, and dissolving the National Party, which he labels "satanic." This aligns with his previous calls, such as his critique of the military's focus on protecting economic interests like "cake ovens and shrimp farms" rather than national security, as seen in his statement, "The army is on alert to protect cake ovens, while leaving border security to 'Abd al-Wadud, the offspring of the Jews.'"
The statement also threatens escalation to armed resistance if the regime does not comply by the end of the next presidential term, stating, "Otherwise, it will turn into armed disobedience if they cling to their political lie, whether through extension or inheritance, and then each incident will have its own story!" This reflects his belief in the necessity of force if peaceful means fail, consistent with his earlier calls to "arm yourselves to succeed" and his support for Palestinian resistance.
Context and Implications
The timing, June 5, is symbolically significant as the anniversary of the 1967 defeat, aiming to mobilize public sentiment against the regime. However, given Egypt's current political climate, where dissent is suppressed under laws like the 2013 anti-protest law, such calls face significant risks. Reports from [BBC News on Egypt's Political Climate]([invalid url, do not cite]) highlight the crackdown on opposition, with thousands arrested, making organized civil disobedience challenging. The regime's reliance on military and security forces, backed by international support from Saudi Arabia and the UAE, further complicates the feasibility of such actions.
Elkotamy's accusations of treason, such as labeling the regime as serving "the Jews and Christians" and receiving "riyals and dinars from Gulf pigs," reflect his view of a conspiracy against Islam, aligning with his support for Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood. This stance is controversial, as it could be seen as incitement, potentially leading to legal repercussions in Egypt, where criticizing the government is criminalized.
The Personal Dimension: The Photo
The attached photo, described as showing Elkotamy with two children in an urban setting, likely Paris, humanizes him. It depicts him wearing a black leather jacket and gray plaid scarf, with the children dressed warmly, suggesting a cold environment. This personal touch, possibly shared to show his family life, contrasts with his political activism, suggesting his motivations are rooted in a desire for a better future for his children and nation. This is an unexpected insight, as it shifts the focus from his fiery rhetoric to his personal stakes, potentially making his calls for change more relatable.
Comparative Analysis with Other Dissidents
Compared to other Egyptian dissidents like Wael Ghonim, known for his role in the 2011 revolution and more moderate tone, Elkotamy's approach is more radical, focusing on Islamist narratives. His language, such as "Gulf pigs" and "satanic organization," is reminiscent of other Islamist critics like those from the Muslim Brotherhood, but his exile in France gives him a platform to reach a broader audience, as seen in his YouTube series on [mktbtalimam YouTube Channel]([invalid url, do not cite]).
Conclusion
Salem Elkotamy's statements are a call for revolutionary action, leveraging symbolic dates and threatening escalation, reflecting his belief in the necessity of overthrowing what he sees as a tyrannical regime. The photo humanizes him, showing his personal life amidst his activism, which might drive his urgency for change. However, the feasibility of his calls is limited by Egypt's repressive environment and international support for the regime, making his vision a long-term aspiration rather than an immediate reality.
Key Citations
- [Human Rights Watch on Egypt's Crackdown]([invalid url, do not cite])
- [BBC News on Egypt's Political Climate]([invalid url, do not cite])
- Salem Elkotamy's Blog
- [mktbtalimam YouTube Channel]([invalid url, do not cite])
- [Protests held at French parliament over al-Sisi visit]([invalid url, do not cite])
- [Human rights in France Amnesty International]([invalid url, do not cite])
ليست هناك تعليقات:
إرسال تعليق